Just paid $22 for a piece of shoe leather calling itself prime rib. I ordered it “raw” & told the waitress I wanted it extra rare. It was well done and tough. My husband ordered a filet which was done rare. When asked if there was bread to go with our salad we were offered pita bread. When asked again about the “prime rib “ the waitress told us it was a rib steak that he cooked not prime rib. At one time this was a high class place with great food. Now it’s more like a sports bar and certainly needs a different cook.
Stopped in on a Monday afternoon, not busy. Had excellent service and food. Prime rib was very tasty.
Just paid $22 for Prime Rib not cooked properly. No choice of potato instead served day before over cooked/ dried out /burnt potatoes that they tried to cover up with a ton of garlic butter and parmesean. Soup on salad was Shrimp Gumbo another burnt dish with chunks of the burnt chunks floating around in it. This place is beautiful. But may do better business if you found a chef with some pride in his work. Extremely disappointed! Should have gone to the Log Cabin instead.
Went here with 6 people and had various dishes from Fettuccine Alfredo to fresh cheesesteaks and hamburgers.Food was delicious and service was awesome especially in that he was short handed. Establishment was very clean including the bathroom.Looks like they take a lot of pride in their business! Highly recommend ,especially coming off the Gorge.Very satisfied with everthing !!!
It's a nice place with a lovely upscale hunting lodge feel featuring lots of beautiful wood work, taxidermy and a warm inviting fireplace. The drinks were fantastic however, that"s where the magic ends. We ordered the buffet and prime rib and both were disappointing. The quality of meat was poor. It's a great place to watch a game but I would recommend you stick to the burger and appetizer menu.
Old Antlers Inn is a US Bar based in Wellsboro, Pennsylvania. Old Antlers Inn is located at 3591 US-6, Wellsboro, PA 16901, USA.
Please contact with Old Antlers Inn using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Old Antlers Inn opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.